Skip to content
Performetic

Ecommerce Growth

How to choose an ecommerce agency: criteria and scorecard

Written by Published Last updated 7 min read
How to choose a digital marketing agency for ecommerce

In short

Choose an ecommerce agency by how it works, not by what it promises. There is no single best agency; the right one derives targets from your margins, audits tracking first, gives you raw data access and leaves your ad accounts in your name. Score candidates on the same criteria, verify badges in official directories and start with a short audit.

Contents7 min read
  1. 01How do you choose an ecommerce agency?
  2. 02Agency, freelancer or in-house team?
  3. 03How can you tell which ecommerce agency is the best?
  4. A scorecard you can use
  5. 04Why are "best agency" lists unreliable?
  6. 05How do you verify partner badges?
  7. 06What should you ask in the first meeting?
  8. 07What are the red flags?
  9. 08What belongs in the contract and the reports?
  10. 09How do you run a short trial or audit?
  11. 10Key takeaways

How do you choose an ecommerce agency?

Judge an ecommerce agency by how it works, not by what it promises. A good one derives targets from your margins, audits tracking before touching campaigns, reports with store data and leaves ownership of your ad accounts with you. There is no universal "best agency"; the best one for you is the one that scores highest on the criteria below.

In full transparency: Performetic is an agency that works with ecommerce brands too. We wrote this as a checklist you can use whoever you hire, and you are welcome to apply the scorecard and the questions to us.

Agency, freelancer or in-house team?

First decide whether you need an agency at all. A brand running one channel on a modest budget can be well served by an experienced freelancer. When Google, Meta, creative production and tracking all need managing together, an agency gives you a broader bench.

Criterion In-house team Freelancer Agency
Brand and product knowledge Very high Medium Medium, grows over time
Breadth of expertise Limited by team size Usually one area Multiple channels and disciplines
Continuity risk Knowledge leaves with employees High dependence on one person Process continues if people change
Best fit High spend, long-term investment One channel, limited budget Multichannel growth, need for fast expertise

As spend grows, many brands move to a hybrid model, with strategy and product knowledge in-house and specialist execution at an agency. We cover the costs and how to set it up in our article on agency vs in-house marketing teams.

How can you tell which ecommerce agency is the best?

Searches like "best ecommerce agencies in Turkey" come from a fair need: a shortlist you can trust. But no single ranking is right for everyone. An agency that does well for skincare brands may be the wrong fit for a furniture store with a high average order value. Your budget, channel mix, platform (Shopify, ikas, Ticimax) and the maturity of your in-house team all change the answer.

A scorecard you can use

Rate each criterion from 1 to 5 and multiply by its weight. The weights add up to 100, so the maximum score is 500.

Criterion Weight What a 5 looks like
Target setting and profitability 20 Derives target ROAS from margin, shipping and return rate
Measurement and data transparency 20 Audits tracking in month one and gives you direct raw data access
Category and platform experience 15 Shows concrete work at a similar order value on your platform
Team and communication 15 You meet the person who runs your account; meeting cadence is written down
Creative and testing process 10 A test plan with written hypotheses and success criteria
Contract and asset ownership 10 Every account is yours and the notice period is reasonable
Verifiable references 10 Lets you speak to a client reference; partner status shows in official directories

Add one rule on top: any agency that scores 1 or 2 on asset ownership or raw data access is out, whatever its total. Fixing either later costs more than a few months with the wrong agency.

Why are "best agency" lists unreliable?

They help you build a long list, not make the decision:

  • An agency often wrote the list. Many such articles sit on agency blogs, with the author in first place.
  • Some positions are paid. Some directories and comparison sites sell top placements without always saying so.
  • Criteria go unstated. If a ranking does not say what data it used or who did the judging, the order means little.
  • Numbers cannot be checked. Claims like "300% growth" without a starting point, time frame or spend are no basis for comparison.

How do you verify partner badges?

A badge on a website is just an image. Check it in the platform's own directory:

  • Google Partner: Search for the agency in the Google Partners directory. Under Google's published requirements, the Partner badge needs an optimization score of at least 70% on the agency's manager account, $10,000 USD in 90-day spend across managed accounts and Google Ads certification for at least half of its account strategists. Premier Partner status goes to the top 3% of participating companies in each country.
  • Meta Business Partner: Check whether the agency appears in Meta's partner directory and in which area it is recognized. If you cannot find it, ask the agency for a link to its directory profile.
  • Shopify Partner: If the agency has a profile in the Shopify Partner Directory, review its services, work samples and client reviews. Partners there are grouped into Select, Plus, Premier and Platinum tiers.

A badge is a good sign, but it proves neither category experience nor who will run your account.

What should you ask in the first meeting?

The answers to these questions reveal far more than a pitch deck:

  1. How do you set targets? A good answer asks about your contribution margin, break-even ROAS and customer lifetime value. We explain how to derive target ROAS from margin in our break-even ROAS guide.
  2. What will you do in the first 30 days? Listen for concrete steps: a tracking audit, an account structure review and a test plan.
  3. How do you validate measurement? Do they reconcile platform data with store orders?
  4. Who will manage my account? Is the person on the sales call the one running it day to day, and what is their experience?
  5. Will I have direct access to the ad accounts and Analytics? Anything short of a clear yes ends the conversation.
  6. What did you get wrong with a similar brand, and what did you learn? An honest answer tells you more than any success story.

What are the red flags?

  • Guaranteed ROAS or revenue. A promise like "we will double your ROAS in three months" cannot be made without seeing your account.
  • The agency owning your ad accounts. If the ad account, Pixel or Merchant Center sits in the agency's name, you lose your history when you leave.
  • No access to raw data. If all you ever get is a PDF and screenshots, you cannot check the results yourself.
  • Long lock-in. A long commitment without a reasonable notice period suggests the agency trusts the contract more than its results.
  • Vague pricing. If what is included is not written down, extra charges show up later.

What belongs in the contract and the reports?

The contract should spell out scope (channels, whether creative and landing page work are included), asset ownership, the fee model, reporting cadence, the notice period and the handover of access and documentation on exit. Grant access through Google Ads user access levels and partner access in your Meta business portfolio, never through your own login.

A good report covers store revenue, total ad spend (blended ROAS), new customers and acquisition cost, results by channel, tests run and priorities for the next period. A report that shows only platform ROAS is incomplete.

How do you run a short trial or audit?

Before a big commitment, test the agency on something small and measurable. Two common routes:

  • Audit: Give read-only access to the ad accounts, Analytics and store admin, and ask for a written list of findings within a week or two. Tracking errors, wasted spend, feed issues and a priority order should all be specific.
  • Pilot: A 60-90 day engagement limited to one channel or one product group. Define success up front with store data, for example new customer acquisition cost, and keep the notice period short.

Do not expect a jump in month one. Depth of diagnosis, quality of communication and willingness to ask you questions show from the first weeks. If you are switching, move every asset into your own business accounts before removing the old agency's access, and keep campaigns running during the handover.

Performetic is one option you can put through the same checklist: an ecommerce agency working with ecommerce brands since 2020, with a remote team serving brands across Türkiye. You can review our published results in our case studies and ask us for proof of our partnerships in the first meeting.

If you want to try the audit step with no commitment, request a free growth analysis through our contact page. We review your ad accounts, tracking and store, and share pricing in writing after that analysis, once the scope is clear.

Key takeaways

  • There is no single best agency; compare candidates with the same weighted scorecard.
  • Verify partner badges in Google, Meta and Shopify's own directories.
  • Guaranteed ROAS, agency-owned accounts, no raw data access and long lock-ins are red flags.
  • Start with a short audit or pilot before a large commitment.

Frequently asked questions

Which is the best ecommerce agency in Turkey?

There is no answer that holds for every brand. Most online rankings are published on agency blogs or include paid placements. A better approach is to build a shortlist from platform directories and references, then score each candidate on the same criteria: margin-based targets, measurement transparency, category experience and asset ownership.

How do I verify that an agency is a Google, Meta or Shopify partner?

Look at the platform's own directory, not the badge on the agency's website. Search for the agency in the Google Partners directory, Meta's partner directory and the Shopify Partner Directory. If you cannot find it, ask for a link to its directory profile. A badge is a good sign but does not prove experience in your category.

Should I give my agency ownership of my ad accounts?

No. Ad accounts, Merchant Center, Analytics and your Pixel should belong to your brand, with the agency given access only. Google Ads offers different access levels, and Meta lets you give a partner access to specific assets in your business portfolio. That way, your accounts and history stay with you if you change agencies.

How should agency fees be structured?

Common models are a fixed monthly retainer, a percentage of ad spend and performance-based fees. A percentage of spend can incentivize increasing budgets; performance fees cause disputes if measurement definitions are vague. Whatever the model, the contract should state clearly what is and is not included.

How long should I give an agency before judging results?

The first weeks usually go into fixing tracking, rebuilding account structure and testing. A meaningful performance evaluation needs a few months. Communication quality, transparency and depth of diagnosis can be judged from the first weeks, though; if those are weak, there is no need to wait.

Sources

  1. How to become a Google Partner or Premier Partner (Google Ads Help)
  2. Google Partners Directory
  3. Shopify Partner Directory
  4. About access levels in your Google Ads account (Google Ads Help)
  5. Give a partner access to assets in your business portfolio (Meta Business Help Center)

Your ad budget deserves more.

We review your store and ad accounts and send you three concrete growth opportunities, free of charge.

Get a free audit
Get a free audit